HomeWarranty Reviews

Updated 2026 · Independent review

Select Home Warranty Review: Is It Worth It?

In our Select Home Warranty Reviews analysis, we looked at the three plan tiers, what's covered, and what real customers say, so you can decide if it's right for you.

Check prices for your home Highly rated by customers

Plans & pricing

Select Home Warranty offers three plan tiers, Bronze, Gold and Platinum, so you can match coverage to your home and budget. Exact pricing depends on your home and location; check current rates and any promotions with Select Home Warranty directly.

Bronze

Appliance coverage

  • Covers major home appliances
  • Entry-level coverage tier
  • Optional add-ons available
Get a quote →

Gold

Systems coverage

  • Covers major home systems
  • Heating, cooling, plumbing and electrical
  • Optional add-ons available
Get a quote →

Platinum

Full home coverage

  • Combines appliance and systems coverage
  • The most comprehensive tier
  • Optional add-ons available
Get a quote →

Coverage summarized from the provider's site; see the official plan agreement for limits and exclusions.

Pros

  • Three clear plan tiers to fit different homes and budgets
  • 24/7 claims reporting
  • Optional add-ons let you tailor coverage
  • Customers frequently praise friendly, knowledgeable sales staff

Cons

  • Exact pricing isn't published online; you need a quote
  • Coverage limits and exclusions apply; read the plan agreement
  • Not available in every state

Select Home Warranty Reviews from Real Customers

Customer review quotes with attribution to their original source.

"I do sleep better at night knowing I have Select Home Warranty. I absolutely do."
Leslie C.Source: selecthomewarranty.com/reviews
"I actually had a great experience. Mr. Tony was my agent both times and both times were seamless and no issues. I received a great price on my single family home for 3.5 years of coverage and thus, I went back for another policy for my 3 unit multi-family home. I'm happy."
Shkera · New York, NY · Posted 05/15/2026Source: selecthomewarranty.com/reviews
"SHW quickly responded to my HVAC problem. A Tech came out the same day and had HVAC up and running the same day. SHW customer service was quick and experienced. Thank you for your help in giving us cool air again in Texas!"
Barbara · Plano, TX · Posted 05/12/2026Source: selecthomewarranty.com/reviews
"Excellent Customer Service! I'm very happy with this company. They made it very easy to purchase a policy, and they gave me multiple discounts on the price. I would definitely recommend them to my friends and clients."
Tomaj · Oakland, CA · Posted 05/06/2026Source: selecthomewarranty.com/reviews
"It was easy to sign up. The company offered a Senior Discount and applied the discount during the call. We received a locked in rate that won't change every year like with other companies. You can take it with you if you move. Low deductible so you don't have to wait to get service."
Regina · Placerville, CA · Posted 05/03/2026Source: selecthomewarranty.com/reviews
"Select Home Warranty was highly ranked in several of the listings I looked at on the internet. The Select Home Warranty representative was knowledgeable and very helpful. The representative made it easy to switch my home warranty to Select Home Warranty and I saved over $1,500 in the process."
Ryan · Seattle, WA · Posted 04/21/2026Source: selecthomewarranty.com/reviews
"A+, Jake was knowledgeable and forthcoming and wanted to help straight out of the bat and not mislead like other insurance companies do. Looking forward to many years of a fruitful relationship. Thanks!"
Chaim · Chicago, IL · Posted 04/20/2026Source: selecthomewarranty.com/reviews
"I called Select around 8 pm on Sunday. They still picked up and provided service. Alan was very polite and explained clearly. He tried selling me other products but was courteous and did not push unnecessarily, which makes conversation much easier."
Rekha · Lake Mary, FL · Posted 04/14/2026Source: selecthomewarranty.com/reviews
"I'm very pleased by the sales staff, well explained of the plan and options offered. I would definitely recommend anyone to this home protection company. I can write more about the interaction but I had everything explained well with a great understanding of the plan and options. Very pleased by the sales staff."
Juan · Wesley Chapel, FL · Posted 04/07/2026Source: selecthomewarranty.com/reviews
"They were very helpful. I am very happy with their service. The price is a very great price too. I am so happy to have found this company. I feel more confident about this so I can rest better knowing my house is covered."
Shelly · Hayward, CA · Posted 04/04/2026Source: selecthomewarranty.com/reviews
"Excellent customer service and care, with a very easy sign up process. The product itself is of excellent quality, and I couldn't be happier with my decision to purchase from this company. I very highly recommend this home warranty to anyone!"
Rachel · Philadelphia, PA · Posted 04/01/2026Source: selecthomewarranty.com/reviews
"Agent was very helpful and friendly. Explained everything that I questioned and was very patient. Calmed any of the concerns that I had with starting with a new company. Definitely made me want to experience Select Home Warranty."
Robin · Wauconda, IL · Posted 03/31/2026Source: selecthomewarranty.com/reviews
"JP our Rep was very helpful in answering our questions. We have had warranty coverage before, so we knew what we wanted, and JP assured us we would get that and more. We like that the price will be guaranteed for 3 years, and we know the value of a policy like this."
Jeanette · Dallas, TX · Posted 03/30/2026Source: selecthomewarranty.com/reviews
"Jake saved me some money when I told him I was a senior. He answered all my questions and concerns. I was concerned about getting contractors out where we live (in a very rural area). He assured me that I would be covered and there are plenty of contractors in my area."
Alvie · Oklahoma City, OKSource: selecthomewarranty.com/reviews
"Great customer service, helped me with the entire process and also saved me money by pointing out the senior Select Home Warranty plan and providing me with all the details including cost for longer term plans."
Bill · Houston, TXSource: selecthomewarranty.com/reviews
"The representative was very professional and helpful with me in choosing the right plan, such as the Platinum quote that included full home coverage for major systems and warranty quote for AC, heat, & appliances."
Ruth · Germantown, TNSource: selecthomewarranty.com/reviews
"I found SELECT HOME WARRANTY via a Forbes Home Warranty comparison in which they ranked #1. From the start, the experience was clear and pressure free. My rep, Jake was a true pro! He was clear with my options and went the extra mile to get me the right plan with the best possible price. I highly recommend SELECT HOME WARRANTY when searching for comprehensive home warranty protection."
Thomas · Miami, FL · Posted 03/23/2026Source: selecthomewarranty.com/reviews
"I couldn't have asked for a better policy, price, length of time covered or a nicer agent. I'm just waiting now for a printed copy of my policy. I recommend Jefferson and Select Home Warranty."
Posted 03/23/2026Source: selecthomewarranty.com/reviews
"Charles was very helpful and courteous in helping me with my service. Charles went above the standard service I expected and repeatedly asked if there was anything else he could do for me. I had canceled a service contract with another warranty company that did not care about our only claim in two years and even though their representative agreed with us nothing was done to satisfy our claim."
Mary · Dade City, FL · Posted 03/22/2026Source: selecthomewarranty.com/reviews
"Your sales representative was very pleasant. He exerted no pressure and was very thorough with his presentation. It was a pleasure to work with him. I felt he was very supportive in helping me make my decision to purchase the program."
Ray · Windsor, CO · Posted 03/21/2026Source: selecthomewarranty.com/reviews
"The customer service was good, they answered all my questions and checked for every possible discount available for my product. My agent was very patient and courteous. They also matched my previous company with much better rates."
Dawn · Atlanta, GA · Posted 03/21/2026Source: selecthomewarranty.com/reviews
"Was very helpful, explained things to me well, I was able to understand the contract well, will be looking forward to using my warranty home coverage. Very helpful to know there are contractors in the area of where I am located."
Mary Jo · MN · Posted 03/18/2026Source: selecthomewarranty.com/reviews
"I recently switched to a new home warranty company over the phone, mainly because they offered me a much better price—and so far, I'm glad I made the move. The sign-up process was quick, simple, and the representative I spoke with was clear and helpful without being pushy. What stood out the most was how easy they made everything. They explained the coverage, answered all my questions, and helped me feel confident about the switch. Saving money while still getting solid coverage is always a win."
Jaizzman · St Louis, MOSource: selecthomewarranty.com/reviews
"I had been shopping all morning, but when I called Jake he seemed patient and knowledgeable. We were able to come to a Platinum Plan and even worked out how to use my Discover card in the future."
Bobbie · Huntsville, TXSource: selecthomewarranty.com/reviews

Ready to protect your home?

See your ZIP code's rate and current promotions in minutes.

Get a free quote